Skip to main content

Attorneys, Notaries & Conveyancers | Garlicke and Bousfield

By Adrienne Alexandra Oliver

The financial consequences of divorce can be complicated, especially when spouses married out of community of property without the accrual system. On 9 October 2026, the Constitutional Court delivered an important judgment in GD v Minister of Home Affairs and Others [2026] ZACC 39. It declared section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act 70 of 1979 unconstitutional and invalid, removing a restriction that excluded certain pension interests from asset redistribution claims.

The ruling changes what may be considered in relevant divorce proceedings. It does not mean that every spouse is automatically entitled to half of the other spouse’s assets or pension interest. The outcome of a redistribution claim remains a matter for the court, based on the applicable law and the evidence.

What does section 7 of the Divorce Act cover?

Section 7 deals with aspects of the financial relief a court may grant when dissolving a marriage. Section 7(3) provides a redistribution remedy in specified circumstances: a court may order that assets, or part of the assets, of one spouse be transferred to the other if it considers that just.

The Constitutional Court’s earlier decision in EB v ER; KG v Minister of Home Affairs [2023] ZACC 32 changed the reach of section 7(3). It removed the restriction that had confined the remedy to certain marriages out of community of property concluded before 1 November 1984. The Court’s interim remedy allowed the redistribution provisions to operate more broadly while legislative changes were pending.

A redistribution order is not an automatic division of the spouses’ estates. The claimant must bring the matter within the statutory framework and provide evidence relevant to a just and equitable order. The court considers the circumstances of the marriage and the spouses’ contributions, which may include direct financial contributions and indirect contributions such as domestic work and family care.

What was the problem with section 7(7)(c)?

Section 7(7)(c) excluded pension interest from redistribution under section 7 in marriages out of community of property without accrual concluded after 1 November 1984.

That exclusion meant pension interest was treated differently from other assets in these cases, despite the broader redistribution remedy recognised after KG. In GD, the Constitutional Court considered whether retaining that exclusion was consistent with the Constitution’s equality guarantee.

What did the Constitutional Court decide in GD v Minister of Home Affairs?

The case concerned GD, who married out of community of property without accrual in 2004. In her divorce proceedings, she sought, among other relief, redistribution involving her former husband’s pension interest. She said that during the marriage she focused on managing the family and supporting his business and personal endeavours.

On 9 October 2026, the Constitutional Court unanimously confirmed the declaration that section 7(7)(c) is unconstitutional and invalid. It found that the provision irrationally differentiated between spouses and unfairly discriminated on the ground of gender by treating women in pre- and post-1984 marriages differently. The Court recognised that unpaid domestic labour and domestic expenses are disproportionately borne by women, while their spouses may have more opportunity to advance their careers and build pension savings.

The Court ordered that the invalidity take effect immediately. As a result, pension interest is dealt with as part of the assets that may be considered for redistribution under sections 7(3) and 7(8), within the interim framework established in KG. The Court stated that its order does not reopen finalised divorces or matrimonial estates that have already been wound up.

Does the judgment guarantee a share of a spouse’s pension?

No. The judgment removes the statutory exclusion; it does not guarantee a particular share or make redistribution automatic. A spouse seeking redistribution still needs to present a case for a just and equitable order. The court may assess contributions made during the marriage, including unpaid work and support that enabled the other spouse to build an estate. The terms of the marriage and the circumstances in which the matrimonial property arrangement was chosen may also be relevant. The judgment does not replace an individual assessment of the evidence in each case.

Who may be affected by the ruling?

The decision is especially relevant to spouses who:

– married out of community of property without accrual;
– are involved in divorce proceedings where one spouse has a pension interest; and
– wish to ask the court to consider redistribution under section 7.

The ruling may also matter to people who are considering divorce and need to understand how their matrimonial property regime interacts with a potential redistribution claim. Whether the order applies to a particular matter depends on its circumstances and procedural history.

What should spouses do next?

Anyone considering a redistribution claim should obtain advice on their marriage regime, the assets and pension interests involved, and the evidence needed to support the claim. Records of financial contributions, caregiving, domestic responsibilities, and support for a spouse’s career or business may help explain how the parties contributed to the marriage and their accumulated assets.

Because the GD order is not retrospective, people whose divorces are finalised or whose matrimonial estates have already been wound up should not assume that the judgment reopens their case. Anyone with a pending matter should get advice on how the ruling and the interim statutory framework apply to their specific proceedings.

Conclusion

The GD v Minister of Home Affairs judgment removes the exclusion of pension interest from redistribution claims in the affected category of divorce matters. Read with the Constitutional Court’s earlier decision in KG, it confirms that pension interest may be considered as part of the assets subject to a section 7 redistribution order. The decision does not promise an equal split or an automatic pension award. It allows the court to assess pension interest alongside the other relevant assets when deciding what redistribution, if any, is just and equitable.

This article provides general information about South African law and is not legal advice. The application of section 7 depends on the facts of each matter.